Worthington High Schools Alumni Club - Deceased Classmates
First Name
Sherry
Maiden Name
Keating
Last Name
Paul
Passing Date
11/11/2026
Class Attended
1962
High School
Worthington High School
She was the best mother…the best human. Funny, kind, humble and authentic. She was the real deal. It’s impossible to encapsulate, in a few short paragraphs, the entirety of who Sherry was and what she meant to us. Sherry Marie (Keating) Paul was born a New Year’s Baby on January 1, 1944 in the middle of a snowstorm in Columbus, Ohio. She was raised in the shadow of ‘The Shoe’ directly across Woodruff Ave. from The Ohio State University and was a life-long Buckeye, rarely missing a football or basketball game in her adult years. A 1962 graduate of Worthington High School, Sherry played girls basketball, swam on the swim team and worked as a lifeguard and swimming teacher at the pool in the summers. She loved the water. From 1980 to 1994, with her dear friend and business partner, Sherry co-owned and operated Paper Moon – a card and gift store that served the Columbus suburbs in three different locations. After Paper Moon closed, she remained in retail over the years and wrapped up her career running the book stores at Mt. Rainier National Park for 12 years. She was the very definition of a hard worker. She was a hopeless romantic who loved poetry and music and art and she had impeccable taste. Sherry had an amazing sense of adventure, always up for planning a trip of any length – even if it was just for a day to explore other towns nearby. On family vacations, she came armed with a bag full of recipes and pre-measured ingredients ready to provide massive meals for the whole family. She was a great cook but also loved the simplicity of a cold pork sandwich with mayo on white bread and the perfect slice of tomato. Local to Worthington, she was a total sucker for Donato’s Pizza (classic Pepperoni), Mark Pi’s and Graeter’s Ice Cream (Blackberry Chocolate Chunk, thank you very much). She devoted every fiber of her existence to her children – getting them to and from rehearsals and competitions, sporting events, scout meetings and play performances, always putting their needs ahead of her own. Known to the friends of the Paul kids as ‘The Shers’, she was also a mother to the whole host of friends her children brought home and was loved and revered by all of them. A select few got to call her Other Mother. Lovingly named Mama Shers when grandchildren came along, she dedicated her free time to flying around the country to keep tabs on her brood and shower them with love, attention and food. Alzheimer’s has stolen the last six years of Sherry from us. We are so grateful she has finally been liberated from the prison within her own brain but will miss her desperately. Sherry was preceded in death by her parents, Earl and Bettie Keating and her sister, Karen. She is survived by her brother, Michael (Nancy), three children and their spouses, Sarah (Michael Wilson), Peter Paul (Julie Hover) and Colby (Chad Kingsbury); grandchildren, Cassidy, Jack, Maggie, Finn, Chloe, Charlie, Ciana and James and one great grandchild, Rose. In lieu of flowers, the family respectfully requests you consider an in-kind donation to one of the following: ACLU, The Harry Chapin Foundation, The National Park Foundation, Alzheimer’s Association, American Stroke Association. We will remain forever grateful that we got to share our lives with Sherry Paul. A hole has now been created that will never again be filled.